Wednesday, June 14, 2017

My Inquiry Idea, Interactive Gallery Walk


Should Students be Allowed to Listen to Music in the Classroom When They Write?

Initially my thought was to pursue the idea of whether or not it was beneficial for students to listen to music in my classroom when they are writing.  I am still considering this as a topic, as I feel it is relevant to what I will be teaching.  Even though I won't be teaching an actual English Language Arts class, I do plan on having students within my technology classes use class time for various activities that will require writing across the curriculum.  I would like to feel confident that I have a tried and tested methodology and response when students will ultimately ask me if they can listen to music in class.



Upon further reflection myself, and after reading comments from my classmates within the Summer Institute, I think there are more questions about this topic to consider.  I don't know if this question will necessarily have a single answer.  Perhaps the best answer to this inquiry idea might be a varied answer.  Maybe music is best allowed for certain types of projects, during certain situations.  Perhaps even certain types of music might better fit different stages of the process... Still thoughts to consider...

Tuesday, June 13, 2017

Inquiry Ideas

What's the backstory to your inquiry?  What interests you?  Why is it of interest and importance at this point in your teaching life?  What personal connections do you have to the topic?

One of the things I have thought about to pursue for my personal inquiry topic is how students listening to music can affect their work in an academic classroom setting in both positive and negative ways.  I have had a lot of personal experience of students always wanting to listen to their music in class while they work on something.  I know that I enjoy filling the air with sound when I work on things, so I am not adamantly opposed to the idea, however I think that often students blindly choose the wrong type of music to listen to when they are trying to focus and work on something in an academic setting.  This poor choice of music then has diminishing returns on their focus, concentration, and ultimately their work output.


Where does your idea come from?  What questions do you have?  What is your goal?
My idea comes from constantly trying to battle with students over the use of music in the classroom.  I feel like if I give the power to students to choose their own music (especially students in the middle school age range) they will choose the wrong type of accompaniment and then not be able to produce work during class.  However, if I take control and pick the type of music for the classroom, even though I know that type of music has been researched and proved to have positive effects, students will still argue that they dislike classical music, or world music, or electronic music, etc.

I have questions about the results of the studies that have been conducted on this topic before and if there is a difference in how the music is delivered to students.  For example, is the music played over a speaker in the classroom for all to hear, or do all students have their own individual sets of headphones?  Also, I would like to know were these studies measuring student output of certain types of academic work (math/science/technology types of activities compared to pre-writing discovery compared to initial writing compared to draft evaluation, etc)?

I would overall like to feel confident in my decision on whether or not to allow music in the classroom based on an analysis of research.  That way I feel I can make an informed decision.

My Teaching Demo: How to Tell a Good Story, The 6 C's of Storytelling

Here are links to all the materials you will need to reference during my teaching demonstration :)

Google Doc, Review Sheet
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kkNsaoCHsrpXpxGoGe-H5YUFhNt4xtxBPOHCJlojspo/edit

Google Form, Your Stories, 6 C's
https://goo.gl/forms/12DzGkIotESz2sBk2

Google Doc, Your Random Emoji String
https://docs.google.com/document/d/190RHWEtlwh40VS4Oi0kvNi-R68-Z9I2IUPxgSLcElko/edit#

Google Slides, My Presentation
https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1s71EJGBcNsblxany-NtHnTUcg2SG9hadxQn8x9TDvE4/edit#slide=id.p

Monday, June 12, 2017

UIWP Summer Institute, First Day!

Some time for reflection on my first day as a participant in the UIWP...

After brief introductions around the table and sorting out our payment paperwork through the university, we were given a brief overview of what our plans will be for the day and for the rest of the week.  Participants will start bringing in student work for analysis beginning this Tuesday and participants will begin delivering their teaching demonstrations beginning this Wednesday.

At this point, I have a solid choice for my own teaching demonstration and I was given the "Thumbs Up" to proceed with it after some discussion today.  I have given a lot of thought and preparation to revisiting one of the foremost and fundamental story lessons I have ever learned:  The 6 C's of Storytelling.  I first learned of this lesson when I was a student at Ventura College in Ventura, CA enrolled in an Introductory Screenwriting class with the one and only Professor Jon O'Brien.  His words and ideas have stuck with me over the years through my time at film school, my time spent working in the industry after college, my time going back to school to earn my teaching certification, and finally through my initial years as a teacher.  I remember teaching this lesson in my 8th grade English Language Arts class my first year as a teacher at UMS and the students really enjoying it and using that lesson as a foundation to discuss and identify story elements in many different works throughout the rest of the year.  I am excited to share this lesson with the rest of the cohort in this year's Writing Project!

We then listened to an example teaching demonstration by Tiffany Bui, the librarian at Leal Elementary School in Urbana, on Zines.  Tiffany not only gave us an overview of what a zine is and how it has evolved over the course of history, but she also shared several examples of published zines to help us get an idea of how diverse zines can be in their subject, content, and style.  Tiffany then shared several examples of student created zines that she has kept from projects she has done with her students at Leal.  Essentially, the most important thing about creating a zine is expression and communication.  Spelling, grammar, usage, punctuation, and all the "boring" parts of writing ideally take a back seat.  There really is no one way to correctly create a zine, as zines are by definition very personal in their nature.  Tiffany closed our her demo by giving us all time to create our own 8 page zine by folding a single sheet of paper and cutting it so that it would resemble a small book.  I choose to write a zine about coffee (some brief history of how and where it was first discovered, what coffee looks like in modern American society, how to order various kinds of coffee, and why people drink coffee).  We then had the instant gratification of having our zine "published" once it was copied onto a piece of colored paper.  Overall, I really enjoyed this process and I will definitely look into exploring this project as something I can do in an electronic form in one of my technology classes next year...

After having lunch on campus, I returned to reflect and write about one of the shared readings, “A Tale of 3 P’s—Penmanship,Product, and Process:  100 Years of Elementary Writing Instruction” by Hawkins and Razali.  During the reflection, I thought what others would think about how I choose to teach writing based on what resources I have in my classroom.  I think that in retrospect, I could provide a few more examples of previous student work for some projects as well as creating some individual instruction sheets and/or examples.  Overall though, I think I choose to heavily show my students how to properly format and set up their scripts and writing projects, but I really try to be very open about what my students choose to write about.

I wasn't really to surprised about what I read in the article.  It seems like the way that writing has been taught over the years has been shifting, especially as things are now really beginning to transition from a world of handwriting to a world of typing... The question remains which skills should be taught to students, when should those skills be taught, and who should be teaching students those skills.

The following discussion was very fruitful, it was refreshing to hear other teacher's frustrations about how they face similar things that I have faced trying to teach writing to students.  Really, the biggest hurdle is to have students accept that good, quality writing is not something that can be knocked out in a single draft.  The thought and act of revision is really the only way to make meaningful and positive gains in one's writing style, tone, and voice... Not to mention it is the simplest and most effective way to catch typos, correct spellings, improve irregularities, and reduce clutter... How to get students to embrace the process that is effective writing remains to be the million dollar question?

One thought I had was to have students orally present final drafts of their writing assignments to the class in either a formal or an informal setting.  This would build in some ownership of their work and would also create incentive for some students to take assignments more seriously knowing that there was actually going to be a physical audience that would hear and offer feedback on their writing.

I have attached my full reflection and discussion notes below.
https://docs.google.com/document/edit?hgd=1&id=1-o2IJJUJnxtXVH8qjlfaqWqyCDntfhacsq0QaeF6LBY

That's enough reflection for today... It's too nice outside not to enjoy it :)